75/47.5 Yogurt


When I became sous vide enabled (controlled water bath, anyway, a proper vacuum chamber is on the to-buy list), it immediately dawned on me that a tightly temperature controlled water bath would be perfect for purposefully growing microorganisms as much as for preventing the growth while achieving perfectly done foods.

Roger has long been a fan of yogurt and yogurt is nothing more than milk fermented by a lactose consuming bacteria of, most commonly, the Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus and Streptococcus salivarius subsp. thermophilus varieties.

And, yes, it has proven incredibly easy, cost effective, and exceptionally delicious to cultivate these bacteria in the milk of your choice using a sous vide rig. Note that you really don’t need a water bath; a cooler, some hot bottles and towels can work well enough.

However, you do need the precision of a water bath to achieve consistent results of the highest quality!

The Recipe

Milk Divided

1. Divide a gallon of milk amongst 5 1-quart Bell canning jars (which aren’t actually 1 quart in many cases — go figure — just divide the milk evenly between them). Lids on loosely!

We often use generic organic whole milk, but low-fat works, too. It cannot be ultra-pasteurized (as ultra-pasteurization breaks down the proteins to the point that the bacteria can’t survive. The implications on the healthiness of said milk are quite bad). Raw milk works beautifully, but is expensive. I’ve been meaning to try a mix of sheep and/or goat with the cow’s milk.

Lately, I’ve taken to using a gallon of 2% mixed with a quart of raw whole milk. The result is a bit richer in flavor and texture while not being the whole fat experience.

Making Yogurt; Scalding the Milk

2. Place in an 75C water bath for ~2 hours (long enough to heat the milk thoroughly to 75C for at least an hour).
3. Cool milk to 47.5C. I find it easiest to scoop out the hot water and replace with cold water to bring the temperature down rapidly.

I usually set the target temp of the water bath to 46C initially. By doing this, the residual heat from the milk will leach out into the water bath and you can tell when it is stable when it holds steady. You can inoculate and bring the temperature back to 47.5C simultaneously (Yogurt cultures will incubate fine up to just above 50C and, in fact, I used to do this at 50C. I’ve since found that 47.5C produces an even better result.). The key is to make sure the milk is solidly below 55C before inoculation, otherwise you’ll run the risk of killing off the live cultures!

Innoculate at 50C

4. Stir in one tablespoon of the plain flavor of your favorite brand of yogurt into each jar. Place lids back onto jar loosely.

You can use previous batches to inoculate new batches, but it is generally recommended that you refresh with new yogurt every few batches. Honestly, I’m not sure how much this matters. It’d seem that as long as you store your live culture yogurt properly, you shouldn’t have any more of an issue than one might with, say, a sour dough starter. Mostly, I end up “starting over” with store bought plain yogurt simply because we eat the previous batch so quickly and we forget to preserve enough to start the next batch!
5. Leave in the water bath for at least 12 hours and up to 24 hours (maybe even longer). The longer they are in the bath, the more greek-like sourness to the yogurt. I usually target 18 hours, maybe 22, and everyone in the family eats the stuff like crazy.


6. Tighten the lid and submerge in ice water to stop the bacteria from continuing reproduction as the temperature falls (more below). You should hear a “pop” as each jar seals itself.

7. Refrigerate. We’ve had jars sit in the fridge for 4+ weeks with no off flavors or nasty bits forming. Others have reported keeping the sealed jars in the fridge for 6+ weeks without issue.

You’ll get a bit of whey on some jars, some more than others, I typically collect the whey and use it in bread making.

Why 80/50? Why 75/47.5?


Update:I’ve since moved to 75C for the scalding portion. No real reason. More importantly, I’ve moved to 47.5C for the incubation portion. This is still 5.5F higher than what various DIY recipes call for (to keep the yogurt cultures safe in the face of inaccurate home thermometers). I find the 2.5C reduction in temperature yields a more consistent texture and flavor while cutting the incubation time down to ~14-18 hours (instead of the ~20 I found ideal at 50C).

Energy savings and a better product!

I’ll leave the rest here for posterity as the Dr. Fankhauser’s research is exceptionally relevant and interesting.

Obviously, 80/50 refers to the two temperatures used. The first temperature isn’t that critical — anything over 65C will work.

That 50C number, though, is quite key. When researching yogurt recipes, I ran across the weblog of David B. Fankhauser, Ph.D, Professor of Biology and Chemistry. My recipe is based on his, but optimized for the water bath method.

Professor Frankhauser makes a very interesting observation. The yogurt making bacteria are thermophilic and, thus, prefer an elevated temperature for ideal growth. They require temperatures above 37C (body temperature, effectively), but won’t grow above 130C. On the other hand, various pathogenic bacteria are also thermophilic and grow in a similar range, with their growth tapering off rapidly (but still dangerous) above ~40C.

Thus, by incubating the yogurt in a water bath at 50C, which is slightly higher than what most recipes call for (but most recipes assume the typical kitchen temperature control of +/- 10C), we can inhibit the growth of the pathogenic bacteria while still maintaining healthy growth of the yogurt producing bacteria.

Not only is this safer, but it yields a far more consistent product in both flavor and texture!

2 Responses to “75/47.5 Yogurt”

  1. Lisa Fetterman says:

    Whoa, yogurt is so easy to make!! Thank you for posting this Bill!

  2. Makanmata says:

    Thanks for a great recipe, which produced my best-ever results making yogurt. I live in a country where real greek yogurt is impossible to find, and now I can reproduce something very close to “Fage” which I consider to be the gold standard. I used to scald the milk in a separate pot, but now I follow your lead and do it all sous-vide in the same Ball jar from beginning to end, which makes cleanup easier. After cooling, I dumped the curd into a paint filter (get them in the paint section of Home Depot for around $1 each), and drained it for around 2 hours. The only problem is that the yield is quite small (less than 50%, as a quart/liter of milk produces less than a pint of drained greek yogurt), so next time I’ll have to make a bigger batch.

Leave a Reply

Line and paragraph breaks automatic.
XHTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>